Example 1 · level 1
Statements: No writers are singers. No singers are dancers. Conclusions: I. Some singers are writers. II. Some writers are dancers.
- Only conclusion I follows
- Only conclusion II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither I nor II follows
- Both I and II follow
Show solution
- Statements as a diagram: No writers are singers; No singers are dancers.
- I (Some singers are writers) is false in at least one diagram the statements allow, so it is not definite.
- II (Some writers are dancers) is false in at least one diagram the statements allow, so it is not definite.
- So the answer is: Neither I nor II follows.
Answer: Neither I nor II follows